January 2 . 1 min read
Spousal support is often one of the most contested issues in a California divorce, particularly in Santa Clara County, where support awards are frequently higher than in many other parts of the state. When one spouse is self-employed, determining the amount of income available for support can become significantly more complex. Unlike a traditional W-2 employee, a self-employed spouse’s income may fluctuate from month to month and may not be accurately reflected on a single paystub or tax return.
These challenges do not mean that spousal support is impossible to establish or enforce. Instead, California courts use a more detailed analysis to determine a self-employed spouse’s true income and earning capacity. Understanding how courts approach this issue can help parties set realistic expectations and prepare for what is often a highly scrutinized part of the divorce process.
Why Self-Employment Complicates Spousal Support Determinations
When a spouse is self-employed, income is rarely consistent or easy to verify. Courts recognize that self-employment can involve fluctuating revenue, seasonal work, and business expenses that do not apply to traditional employment. At the same time, courts are cautious not to allow self-employment to be used as a way to reduce spousal support obligations artificially.
Some of the most common challenges courts encounter with self-employed income include:
- Monthly or seasonal income fluctuations, particularly in industries like construction.
- Revenue that depends on external factors, such as weather or market conditions.
- The absence of regular paystubs or employer-issued wage statements.
- Business expenses that may reduce taxable income but not actual cash flow.
Because of these variables, courts must look beyond surface-level financial documents to assess what income is truly available for support.
How California Courts Look Beyond Tax Returns
Many people assume that a tax return tells the full story of a self-employed spouse’s income. In spousal support cases, that is often not the case. While tax returns are an important starting point, they are only one piece of the overall financial picture.
Courts commonly review additional financial records and may scrutinize whether claimed business expenses are legitimate and necessary.
In doing so, courts may consider:
- Profit and loss statements prepared for the business.
- Whether claimed expenses are ordinary and necessary for business operations.
- Expenses that provide a personal benefit but are listed as business deductions.
- Items such as depreciation, which may be deducted for tax purposes but added back as income available for support.
This analysis allows the court to distinguish between taxable income and actual earning ability, ensuring that spousal support is based on financial reality rather than accounting strategies.
Add-Backs and Income Available for Support
One concept that often surprises parties in self-employment cases is the idea of “add-backs.” Certain deductions that reduce taxable income do not necessarily reduce the funds available to pay spousal support.
Courts may add back income for support purposes when they determine that an expense does not represent an actual out-of-pocket cost or is not essential to the business.
Common examples include:
- Depreciation of business assets.
- Personal expenses paid through the business.
- Excessive or discretionary business write-offs.
Add-backs help the court arrive at a more accurate picture of a self-employed spouse’s financial capacity, even when tax filings suggest a lower income.
When a Forensic Accountant May Be Needed
In some cases, the financial records of a self-employed spouse are incomplete, inconsistent, or difficult to interpret. When the numbers do not align or when income appears understated, additional professional assistance may be required.
A forensic accountant may be brought in when:
- Business records are disorganized or unreliable.
- There is a significant gap between reported income and the spouse’s lifestyle.
- The business involves substantial cash transactions.
- Disputes over income calculations cannot be resolved through standard documentation.
Forensic accounting can help quantify income available for support and provide the court with a clear, defensible financial analysis.
Why Legal Strategy Matters in Santa Clara County Spousal Support Cases
Spousal support determinations involving self-employed spouses are rarely straightforward. Courts expect detailed financial evidence, careful analysis, and credible explanations of income fluctuations and expenses. Without a strategic approach, these cases can drag on and become contentious.
At Feak & Revelo, LLP, our San Jose family law attorneys understand how Santa Clara County courts evaluate self-employed income and what evidence is needed to support or challenge spousal support requests. Our attorneys work closely with clients to identify the right tools, financial records, and expert support necessary to present a clear and accurate financial picture.
If you are involved in a divorce in which spousal support is at issue, and your spouse is self-employed, experienced legal guidance can make a meaningful difference. Contact Feak & Revelo, LLP at (408) 501-8883 or online today to speak with our San Jose family law attorneys about how spousal support is determined and what steps may be appropriate in your case.
49 views
